Commentary for Avodah Zarah 103:19
מאי איריא דקא מיבעיא ליה ריתך כלי תיבעי ליה עשה
But why does he specifically ask about “one who welded a vessel”? Let him ask about one who made a vessel!
Daf Shevui to Avodah Zarah
Why does R. Hamnuna ask about a vessel that was repaired? Why not ask about a vessel made to be used in idol worship? The answer is that he is really referencing the idea that comes up in a mishnah (Kelim 11:1). Metal vessels are subject to impurity. If they are broken they become pure but if they are repaired they automatically resume their previous impurity. This mishnah refers to normal types of impurity, those found in the Torah (such as contact with the dead, a sheretz or a person with skin disease). But does the same apply to the rabbinic impurity accorded to idols? Does the vessel, previously used in idol worship, immediately become prohibited when it is repaired?
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy